Patent troll accuses Apple of infringing 16 patents in respect of iCloud, macOS, iOS, more

A lawsuit filed filed by a patent troll in – you guessed it – the Eastern District of Texas accuses Apple of infringing no fewer than 16 separate patents. It was filed by Seven Networks …











The Eastern District of Texas is usually chosen by patent trolls as the court has a track-record of favoring claimants in infringement cases. So much so that Apple is tomorrow closing its two retail stores there, so that it will no longer have a legal presence in the district, making such litigation more difficult. Apple is replacing the stores with a new one located outside of the Eastern District, set to open on Saturday.

The lawsuit makes direct reference to the two stores, still open at the time of filing, as part of its argument that the court has jurisdiction.

Apple has offered and sold and continues to offer and sell these infringing products and services in this district, including at physical Apple stores located within this district.

While Seven Networks claims to be a technology innovator in its own right, citing several awards in its filing, the patents referenced were all purchased by the company. Patently Apple notes that issuing lawsuits appears to be the company’s only activity, the key characteristic of a patent troll.

The company seems to be inactive other than suing other companies and running a blog on their site. Their last press release was made in 2014 and the last time they were covered by the media was in that same year.

The alleged infringements cover a wide variety of ground, including both the way that iCloud operates and specific device features.

  • Method and Device for Power Saving for Downloading Files
  • Mobile Device Power Management in Data Synchronization Over a Mobile Network
  • System and Method for Providing a Network Service in a Distributed Fashion to a Mobile Device
  • Intelligent Alarm Manipulator and Resource Tracker
  • Mobile Application Traffic Optimization
  • Connection Architecture for a Mobile  Network
  • System, Method, and Computer-Readable Medium For User Equipment Decision-Making Criteria For Connectivity and Handover
  • Secure End-To-End Transport Through Intermediary Nodes
  • Mobile Device Configured for Communicating with Another Mobile Device Associated with an Associated User
  • Multiple Data Store Authentication
  • Messaging Centre for Forwarding E-mail
  • Predictive Fetching of Mobile Application Traffic
  • Optimizing Mobile Network Traffic Coordination Across Multiple Applications Running On a Mobile Device
  • Connection Architecture for a Mobile  Network
  • Secure End-To-End Transport Through Intermediary Nodes
  • Multiple Data Store Authentication

The titles of most of the patents suggest that they describe broad approaches commonly used by a great many companies. The underlying issue is approval of way too many patent applications for things people already do. These are then purchased by patent trolls for the specific purpose of going after companies with deep pockets, with Apple a common target.

ESR iPad Accessories

Photo: Shutterstock


You can follow iPhoneFirmware.com on Twitter, add us to your circle on Google+ or like our Facebook page to keep yourself updated on all the latest from Apple and the Web.